Would Tyra Banks win "America's Next Top Model" with makeup like that?

Tyra hit the red carpet at to 2012 Moth Ball in NYC last night sporting some extreme black eyeshadow and crazy bright pink lips.

The model's overall look was very severe, especially when compared to other stars at the event like Padma Lakshmi and Tiffani Thiessen ... who kept it low key in tank tops and LBDs.

What do you think of Tyra's style -- is it too over the top or just right for her? Sound off below.

See more makeup disasters in the gallery above!

Hot Videos