It’s two stars in the same beautiful (but, seasonally inappropriate) dress – so who wore it better?

Olivia Munn donned the Valentino Resort 2012 dress to the 8th Annual Pink Party in Los Angeles on Saturday. She finished her look with tan Valentino Rockstud pumps and styled her hair up parted down the middle.

We love the dress but Munn must have missed the memo that floral prints are typically designated to spring and summer styles ... and that wasn’t her only fashion faux pas!

Fellow fashion offender, Christina Ricci, wore the dress first back in September to the Elle Fashion Next Runway Show during the Spring 2012 Fashion Week in New York City. Ricci completed her outfit with black pumps and likewise wore her hair in an updo.

Even though we’re not fans of Ricci’s black heels with the summery dress, we think the Valentino ensemble fits her much better than Olivia (we just wish she had her shoes too!).

Who do you think wore it better? Sound off below and click “Launch Gallery” above to see all the stars in dueling dresses.

Hot Videos