Two Hollywood starlets in the same stunning LBD … but who wore it better?

Amy Adams donned the Giorgio Armani black dress to the 2012 Gotham Independent Film Festival in New York on Monday.

The radiant redhead accessorized her look with Lorraine Schwartz green diamond tear-drop earrings, a diamond flower ring and black Brian Atwood ankle-strap pumps. Adams went with a simple bun, nude lip and smokey eyes to complete her look.

Amy wasn’t the first to sport the elegant ensemble – Amber Heard wore the dress a whopping three and a half years earlier! The blonde bombshell donned the designer duds to the premiere of "Pineapple Express" back in 2008.

Heard definitely made the look her own, pairing the black LBD with chunky gold and black bracelets, open-toe black and gold pumps, and gold earrings. She completed her look with her signature pin-up hairstyle and a pink lip.

We think both the ladies look drop dead gorgeous in Giorgio Armani … but, we have to give the nod to Amber. Her accessories make her pop more on the red carpet, and the shorter hemline keeps it chic and sexy.

Who do you think wore it better? Click “Launch Gallery” above to vote and sound off below!

Hot Videos