Is it even fair to pit anyone against a 19-year-old Victoria's Secret Angel?

Perhaps not, but we're putting Alyssa Milano up to the challenge. The actress wore this nude Robert Rodriguez Collection tube dress to the 2013 Winter TCA Tour earlier this month. Alyssa accessorized with a multicolored necklace, matching bracelet and a chic updo.

Back in July, model Bregje Heinen wore the same dress to a Body By Victoria Collection launch in New York City. Bregje, who you might recognize from the Victoria's Secret Fashion Show and Maroon 5's "Payphone" video, paired her look with gold hoop earrings and a bar necklace. A snakeskin belt cinched her already tiny waist.

So, who wore it better?

Alyssa looks great, but we have to give the nod to Bregje. The dress' simple silhouette and color begs for a bold belt to give it pop. We also prefer the her black peeptoes; Alyssa's are a little too matchy-match. Finally, we feel Bregje's is more seasonally appropriate. This is a great dress for summer, not so much for winter.

Click on the "Launch Gallery" above to cast your vote and see more dueling dresses!

Hot Videos