It's a style showdown between a daytime talk show host and a silver screen siren! 

Jenny McCarthy brought the glamour in this blue Stella McCartney gown with a plunging neckline and revealing back at the 2014 Creative Arts Emmy Awards in Los Angeles on Saturday.

"The Talk" cohost completed her elegant ensemble with a crystal-embellished handbag, oversized earrings and tousled curls.

Meanwhile, Shailene Woodley sported the same dress at the London premiere of "Divergent" back in March.

The "Fault In Our Stars" actress paired the gorgeous gown with a Lina Noel snake bangle, a small gold necklace and her signature pixie cut.

While we think both ladies look lovely in the fancy frock, we prefer Shailene's simple styling.

But your opinion is the only one that counts -- who do you think wore it better? Cast your vote, and "Launch Gallery" above to see more stars in dueling dresses!

Hot Videos