Keri Russell was forced to make a tough choice between your '90s faves.
The star of "The Americans" and husband Matthew Rhys were both guests on "Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen" on Thursday, where she was put in the hot seat for a round of Plead the Fifth.
The first question: Who would she shag, marry or kill out of her former "Mickey Mouse Club" co-stars Justin Timberlake, Ryan Gosling and JC Chasez?
At first, Russell was going to plead the fifth on this one, until Cohen warned her she might want to save that pass for her final question.
Everett Collection
Her reasoning for choosing who she did was actually pretty sound, opting to shag JT because if he's a good dancer, he's probably good in the sheets. She'd kill JC, but only because he was her friend and he'd "understand," leaving Gosling left to marry.
Rhys agreed with her choices, saying Gosling would make a good hubby because "he's Canadian, he's nice."
For Cohen's final two questions, he also asked Russell about the accuracy of the prosthetic penis Rhys wore on a recent episode of "Girls" and who she considers the "most overrated actress working today."
Take a wild guess which one she plead the fifth on.
