"He's so much fun," Morgan said when pressed by Andy Cohen whether or not she dated Nicholson. "Who hasn't? Don't forget how old I am, and don't forget those days before cell phones, with the old answering machines."
"That's something to be proud of!" delighted co-guest Michael Rapaport said. "That's an American treasure, man!"
When Cohen coerced Morgan into clarifying whether "dating" meant more than one night with the Hollywood legend, she said, "Nobody nails down Nicholson" and added that their encounter was "one big sloppy mess."
The game also revealed that Morgan wouldn't date Bernie Sanders, the Dalai Lama, David Letterman, Vladimir Putin, Bill Gates, Prince Charles, Gary Busey or Donald Trump -- despite a photo of the future president and Morgan together in New York.
"We're friends," she said. "I went to his wedding, his [ex-wife's] Ivana's wedding, and friends separately. Friends of the family."