The women were discussing Clinton's conversation with journalist Christiane Amanpour at a Women for Women International event in NYC on Tuesday, where the presidential candidate blamed Wikileaks, James Comey and misogyny for her loss, before accepting some of the blame herself when pressed further.
"This was the most unimpressed I've been with Hillary Clinton," Jedediah Bila said right off the bat. "Every time I see her do an interview, I'm waiting for a moment when she doesn't blame anybody but herself and acknowledges why they lost."
Bila then listed off the reasons why she believes Clinton isn't the 45th president of the United States.
"The reason she lost was that her foreign policy at the State Department was a disaster; her intervention in Libya led to terrorist havens and the infiltration of ISIS; she lost because she picked a bad vice presidential candidate; she didn't do proper groundwork in states like Wisconsin, in states like Michigan, Pennsylvania; she lied to people [about the e-mail server]."
Whoopi Golberg interrupted to say, "Please don't bring up lying, because if we're gonna compare ... I can hear you on the other stuff, but the lying I just can't handle."
Sarah Haines -- who admitted she did vote for Hillary -- said she was also "shocked" by Clinton's explanation.
"I tend to agree [with Bila]. I think there was a moment after the election where so many of us stopped after looking at the polls and buildup and went, 'What did we miss?' In some ways, I think she might still be missing some of it. I think there were messaging problems. She wasn't on the ground."
"She got 3 million more votes than Donald Trump did, so her message was out there, people wanted to vote for her," Sunny Hostin interjected.
But Bila argued that elections aren't won by the popular vote and Clinton is a "seasoned politician" who knew "those states she skipped out on, the states she didn't go to, cost her the election." Bila went on to criticize Clinton for not being a "good candidate."
"She would have made a great president, but she was not a great candidate," Joy Behar added. "He was an interesting candidate and a lousy president. Let's face it, Putin wanted to make America great again."
Goldberg closed out the conversation by saying, "We're never gonna know why she lost."
"The waters are so muddy between Wikileaks, Pukileaks, it's too muddy to know," she continued. "I do know we'll never know now because it's so muddy and so disgusting. We've never seen an election like this. I don't think either side can really take a lot of solace because they won or lost... I think both sides should be questioning what the hell has gone on and how did we get here. It's like everything was a mess, between Russia, Wikileaks, Comey ... we don't know what happened. you saw Russia involved, but we will never know had they not been part of it what the real outcome would have been and that's the saddest part for our country."
Before cutting to a commercial break, Behar added, "They're blaming her for not having a message. His message was blame the Mexicans."