Kelly Ripa left Andy Cohen and husband Mark Consuelos absolutely speechless on Tuesday's "Watch What Happens Live" after a caller put her on the spot during a game of "Marry, Shag, Kill: Gay Best Friend Edition."
The caller gave Ripa the options of Cohen, Anderson Cooper and Jake Shears, which left her stumped.
Kelly Ripa Auditions for 'American Idol' and Katy Perry Is Far From Impressed
View Story"Oh, my God!" she said. "No, I'm drowning myself. I can't. I can't."
Cohen gave Ripa the green light to "kill [him], marry Anderson and screw Jake," but she wasn't totally sold on the idea. Mind you, her husband was sitting right next to her.
"Can't we do like a DP and a marry?" she asked. If you're unsure of what a DP is, please Google it on your own time.
"A DP?!" Cohen replied in absolute shock. Consuelos couldn't even wrap his mind around what he had just heard.
"This is all hypothetical, right?" Kelly asked. The audience was dead silent aside from the loud chuckles of a few guests. "That's too far?!"
"Oh, my God. Oh, my God," Cohen kept saying. "I love it! That was one of my favorite things you've ever said."
Fast-forward to 3:07 in the video above to watch the priceless moment.
'RHOBH' Reunion Tea Time: Lisa Rinna Explodes on Lisa Vanderpump Over Instagram Posts -- 'Who Gives a F-cking Sh-t?'
View StoryLater during a game of "Three-Way or No Way," Cohen asked the couple if they'd be down to share a bed with Anderson Cooper, Cardi B, Bethenny Frankel, The Rock, Lisa Rinna, Hoda Kotb and Kathie Lee Gifford, Regis Philbin, Jimmy Kimmel and, of course, Cohen.
We won't say who made the cut, but this couple is down for just about anything. Watch the video below.