"God where do you guys all find the same men," quipped Dorinda. "Where am I? Home in bed."
Afterwards, fans traded their theories about who the mystery man was online and the consensus appeared to be Constantine Maroulis.
"So it was Constantine Maroulis, wasn't it?" shared one follower, as another posted a series of photos of Tinsley and Constantine together, writing, "Why did nobody tell me that Tinsley dated Constantine from American Idol?"
Although the 44-year-old singer did not win the fourth season of the reality singing competition -- he came in sixth -- fans believe the clues line up for him being the guy who has now dated at least three of the "RHONY" ladies.
Check out some of the hilarious reactions to the theory below!
LuAnn implying she “has a story” about “a hot guy” (that LuAnn is showing Dorinda pics of) and Dorinda agrees & says he’s“very sexy” and w whom “Tinsley has dated” & Romona also claims to “have a story about”......