Betty Who Shocks 'One That Got Away' Contestant By Revealing She Made Out with His Ex Too! (Exclusive)

In this deleted scene from the penultimate episode of the show's first season, the singer sits Jeff down to reveal her past love connection with the guy's former flame.

"So, there's something I have to tell you. You came here to make a connection from your past ... someone from your past actually has more than one connection here," she says, surprising Jeff.

"Okay, what does that mean?" he asks, before she drops the bombshell. "I actually have a relationship with Taylor outside of the show," she reveals, sparking a "What?!" from the contestant.

"Taylor took me on a date when I was 16. He took me to coffee, there was a snowstorm, so he took me home early and we made out against his car," she shared -- before the two bonded with a laugh over Taylor being a "great kisser."

Betty shared that when she saw Taylor walk through The Portal on the show, revealing himself to Jeff for the first time, she "screamed" realizing her own connection to him. "You screamed when I was internally screaming as well?" joked Jeff -- as she added, "Yes, we were screaming together!"

So, is Taylor "The One" for Jeff?