Twitter Reacts to John Krasinski's Sexiest Man Alive Title -- Who They Wanted Instead!

The 45-year-old actor takes the title from 2023 honoree Patrick Dempsey, with the official announcement coming late Tuesday night on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert. His cover was unveiled on the show, as well as social media.

Following the announcement, people took to X, formerly Twitter, to share their thoughts, with many fans expressing their disappointment as an apparent large group of people were predicting actor Glen Powell to take the crown after he shot to superstardom -- and quickly became a heartthrob in the process -- within the past two years following roles in 2022's Top Gun: Maverick, 2023's Anyone But You, and Twisters.

However, PEOPLE doesn't always pick someone who is at the height of fame at a certain time, like with Dempsey last year. It's also worth nothing that anyone on the cover has to agree to a big promotional push, so there are people who turn it down.

"like i don’t disagree. john krasinski and jim halpert changed the trajectory of my life but one thing about People magazine… they're gonna make a man SMA in the wrong year every single time," one user wrote.

"John Krasinski is People’s Sexiest Man Alive in 2024……. Another devastating Tuesday night in November," second fan joked, referring to the 2024 presidential election, while another said, "The answer to People’s Sexiest Man Alive is Glen Powell…and even if it’s not, it’s still Glen Powell."

Another fan shared a popular GIF of Powell from Twisters, in which he struts in the rain while wearing a white t-shirt and a cowboy hat. "you're not gonna sit here and tell me that glen powell didn’t solidify his spot as the sexiest man alive after wearing a white t shirt and a cowboy hat in the pouring rain," the person wrote alongside the GIF.

Powell even started trending on X, with many praising the actor's Vanity Fair Hollywood Issue photoshoot, which was released the morning after Krasinski was announced as the Sexiest Man Alive. Fans were loving Powell's photos, which included a sizzling shot that featured the 36-year-old actor rocking a brown see-through mesh polo.

"This photo of Glen Powell with his nipple out being released on the same day of John Krasinski’s Sexiest Man Alive photoshoot? OMG I'D LIKE TO REPORT A MURDER," a user wrote on X.

See more viral reactions in the posts, below!

Despite some mixed reviews online, Krasinski got the only approval that matters: from his wife Emily Blunt.

While speaking with PEOPLE, the Jack Ryan star said Blunt was "very excited" when she learned about his honor. "There was a lot of joy involved in me telling her," he added.

PEOPLE added that Blunt previously joked about using his cover as wallpaper for their home if he was named Sexiest Man Alive.

"Do we have that on camera? Because that's like a binding contract, I think," said Krasinski, who shares daughters Hazel, 10, and Violet, 8, with Blunt. "My children will love that, it won’t be weird at all."