Outside of the Elton John AIDS Foundation's annual Academy Award viewing party, Jenner walked up to the "Chromatica" artist and remarked that she hadn't seen her at their local Malibu Starbucks in a long time.
"Are you spending time around Malibu anymore?" the reality star asked, to which the "House of Gucci" actress replied with a firm, "Yes."
One fan took to Twitter and wrote, "I've switched baristas will now be my excuse to everything," while another tweeted, "'I've switched baristas' is literally the most polite way of saying 'If I ever see you again it'll be too soon.'"
"Finding out that Lady Gaga changed her coffee spot because of Caitlyn Jenner was not on my 2022 bingo card… BUT I AM HERE. FOR. IT," a user commented.
Jenner, however, seemed unfazed by Gaga's apparent dismissal and even tweeted at the singer, praising her presentation for the Best Picture award with Liza Minnelli.
The reality star applauded her by calling the singer "a class act," she wrote, "@ladygaga an absolute class act and this moment truly brought tears to my eyes to see you presenting with @LiZaOutlives." Although the Olympian had good intentions, she accidentally tagged a fan account for the "Cabaret" star.