Starting at the 3:28 mark above, Andy Cohen took a question from a man in the audience, inviting him and his girlfriend to the stage. The move, however, was a ruse ... as he revealed his question wasn't for Andy or guests Bronwyn Newport and Melissa Gorga, as he instead got down on one knee and popped the question. She, of course, said yes. Cohen revealed the proposal happened after the man reached out to him on Instagram, asking for tickets to the show while in NYC to propose. Andy suggested he do it at the Clubhouse.