Sofia and Nick ended up calling it quits soon after, and lucky for the brunette beauty, the "Magic Mike" star has had a crush on Vergara for years now.
The actress is currently filming "Don't Mess With Texas" in New Orleans with Reese Witherpoon, and sources close to the mag say that Manganiello even visited the Colombian actress over the 4th of July holiday weekend.
"Sofia is Joe's dream girl!," the insider revealed. "He's been smitten with her for years. He's always had a huge crush on her. Things are going well for them so far." A different source added, "Sofia had no idea that he had been crushing on her for a while."
Well, they sure make one sexy couple! Are your surprised by the news? Tell toofab in the comment section below and click "Launch Gallery" above to see even more surprising celebrity couples!