Brown first appeared on Colton Underwood's season of the show, before fronting "The Bachelorette," on which Weber was a contestant and placed third. In her upcoming novel "God Bless This Mess," she writes that while the two hooked up, their emotional connection had faded away.
"The chemistry just wasn't there, it just sucked," Brown wrote -- via PEOPLE -- about the experience. "And then, I found out he had another girl [runner-up Madison Prewett] on his mind. It was all so bizarre."
Weber too admitted that their connection wasn't quite the same.
"I agree with what she said. It wasn't the same as I think we had originally felt," he told listeners. "But, nonetheless, it was great to talk and just have someone that kind of understood where I was coming from."
It seems there are no hard feelings on either side, with Weber extending an invitation to Brown to appear on his podcast and Hannah telling PEOPLE she has "no ill will" toward anyone.
On his season, Peter wound up proposing to Hannah Ann Sluss, though they called it quits before the season finished airing. He eventually started dating fifth runner-up Kelley Flanagan and the two were together for 10 months.
Flanagan seemingly commented on the drama surrounding Hannah and Peter by posting a selfie her her holding up a peace sign to her Instagram Story with the caption, "Damn, looks like I needs to write a book. Book coming 2022, maybe 2023."