Adam Levine basically turns his back on one of his own contestants to lobby for another who didn't even perform.
The way eliminations work on "The Voice" at this stage is that the bottom three contestants must each perform again during the results show to try and earn the single "Instant Save" (vote) of the night, with only one of them getting it. The only problem was that one of those contestants, we were told by host Carson Daly, was too sick to perform.
Team Adam's Reagan Strange was "under the weather," which meant she was all dolled up with hair and makeup, but in a very nicely pressed bathrobe backstage. Meanwhile, Team Blake's Dave Fenley was able to perform again, alongside another of Adam's contestants, DeAndre.
But it was after those performances that Adam earned the outrage machine that sent "The Voice" into the top trending topics on Twitter. That's because the show made the unusual decision of still making Reagan available for saving, even though she didn't perform.
They didn't even replay her performance from the night before, so there was literally zero vocal performance to base an instant save on. After the guys performed, Blake Shelton did his job, shilling hard for his guy. Then Adam, who had the job of shilling for both of his contestants even if only one could be saved, basically ignored DeAndre to lobby for Reagan.
"There is an unbelievably talented little girl right now who is not able to fight for her position on this show," he said as DeAndre stood awkwardly on the stage in front of him. "I have two little girls at home. The thought of breaking [Reagan's] heart by not urging everyone to give this girl a shot to redeem herself next week would be too far beneath me."
He continued, speaking to DeAndre directly, "I want you to know I love you. I appreciate what you did here tonight. Honestly, I think you should both be there. But I've got tonight for my girl. I have to fight for her properly, because she didn't have a voice to fight tonight. That's all I can say. It's weird."
Kelly Clarkson decided she had to jump in after Adam basically said nothing about DeAndre, trying to defend her fellow coach while propping up the dejected contestant.
"I know Adam loves his team. He feels really bad for Reagan. DeAndre, you just sang the hell out of that song," she said. "I just wanted to say I know it's so horrible that Reagan is not able to present herself. That's where it's coming from. He's bummed for her."
Then Adam doubled down, by offering his condolences to DeAndre before the results were even revealed. "You have a lot of fans. Take those fans and build upon those fans and make a career for yourself, regardless of what the outcome is right now."
That doesn't sound like someone who believes in his guy, and Twitter fans picked up on all that shade. As they saw it, Adam was totally throwing DeAndre under the bus in favor of Reagan. Admittedly, she probably has the better chance at winning if her performance on Apple streaming is any indication (number one for the past two weeks). Meanwhile, DeAndre was in the bottom for the second week in a row.
But while it might make sense strategically, it still played out way too cold for many viewers. In the end, Regan edged DeAndre out by one percentage point, 38 to 37, to score the save. Fans were so outraged, that #VoiceSaveDeAndre spent the evening trending way higher than #VoiceSaveReagan, with the latter even falling out of the Top 10.
And you can be that added fuel to the fire as DeAndre was sent home and Regan carries on. Check out some of the most impassioned responses below and then get ready for it all to happen again next week as four contestents will get the boot!
Adam is officially the worst coach on the planet. And how the hell is DeAndre supposed to work with a coach who literally just threw him under the bus??? I'm disgusted by Adam right now. #TheVoice #VoiceResults— Richard (@alltvallshade) December 5, 2018
#TheVoice #voicesavedeandre DeAndre was awesome and won the battle. #AdamLevine , your push for Reagan was unfair and completely awkward. DeAndre was completely gracious as you undermined and discounted his performance and value. DeAndre is the star in my book.— Laura Peters (@laurabpeters) December 5, 2018
Well, I'm out... she had one of the worst performances last night and then her coach threw one of his own team members under the bus to save her when she couldn't even perform tonight? Someone let me know who wins, I'm not wasting my time with the rest of the season. #TheVoice pic.twitter.com/7ObrPKjx3c— Jenna Lyn (@jaaaay_okay) December 5, 2018
Adam Levine out here trying to make sure no one ever picks him on The Voice again #TheVoice— Taylor Nunn (@t_nunn12) December 5, 2018
I think the voice executives need to rethink tonight's results. I think a redo is in order based on Adam's behavior. #TheVoice— cathleenc (@cathleenc17) December 5, 2018
Public Service Announcement: Future #TheVoice contestants (especially POC), don't choose this guy as your coach, unless he's the only chair available. He's a careless and embarrassing idiot. #DeAndre deserved better than to be publicly humiliated. So gross. pic.twitter.com/meUwUNSwlb— Gigi F. Diaz (@voidofchill) December 5, 2018
Adam made it sound like DeAndre doesn'tdeserve to be there but Reagan does. To me it was like he was belittling DeAndre. That's not good as a coach in my opinion. Thankful for Kelly's comment to DeAndre. #TheVoice— Martha (@Martha10609427) December 5, 2018
#TheVoice new rule the coaches should not be able to comment before the instant save. That was the most disrespectful and most sh*tty thing a coach could do.— TheLishamoe 28 (@lishamoe28) December 5, 2018
DeAndre showed a lot of class. Too bad his coach didn't. That child also needs to know that sometimes you win, sometimes you lose. Tonight Adam was the loser! #TheVoice— Laura E Julien (@LauraEJulien2) December 5, 2018
#THEVOICE Adam!youve single-handedly ruined this wonderful show for so many tonight. You should be ashamed. If you wanted to talk about Raegan, you should NEVER have done it during DeAndre's time to be fought for. So sad. Shameful.— phyl dav (@pcarpdav) December 5, 2018
Shameful.— bertSmith (@bertSmi97739746) December 5, 2018
The Producers should have disqualified her (come back next year), and folks are rightly *furious* @adamlevine for completely throwing DeAndre under the bus after he sung amazing to save himself.
Adam has done some damage to the Voice brand #thevoice
I am still in shock! What just happened tonight! My heart bleeds for DeAndre the look on his face like he was just hit by a Mack truck. Disgusting 😡 I have officially lost all respect for Adam Levine, not cool!! Kelly you are a class act for speaking up for DeAndre #TheVoice— Shelly Seefeldt (@s_seefeldt) December 5, 2018
#TheVoice@KellyClarkson— Debra Rivers (@DeeRivers128) December 5, 2018
Kelly you're the Girl. Thanks for showing DeAndre some love after Adam dropped him like that. The hurt was on his face. Thanks girl you rock.
#TheVoice Adam Levine did not display the qualities of a coach. The way he totally disregarded the fact that DeAndre had just performed and spoke on behalf of someone who did not perform was totally disrespectful.— Yolanda (@Yolanda59094180) December 5, 2018
Got a story or a tip for us? Email TooFab editors at firstname.lastname@example.org.