Trying to speak for Trump supporters, McCain said she lives "5 miles away from MAGA hat people" and said they're "not convinced what happened is an impeachable offense."
"What about the Constitution?" asked Joy. "I have a copy of the Constitution on my nightstand," McCain shot back, "So please don't talk to me about the Constitution!"
"The Constitution belongs to all of us, whether we have it on our nightstand or not," Joy responded, before adding, "I believe bribery is listed as one of the impeachable offenses, by the founding fathers."
McCain then pointed to Congressman Will Hurd, who said he would vote no on impeachment, believing the evidence so far hasn't been "compelling, overwhelming, clear and unambiguous." Tensions flared again as Sunny expressed shock over Hurd's stance.
"I think that anyone that was listening heard 9 people testify as to what they saw, what they heard, people that have served our country, someone who has a purple heart," she began, before McCain interjected. "He served our country, he's part of the CIA," she interrupted.
"I also say it tells me he is complicit, the Republican party has enabled this president and continues to enable this president," Hostin continued. "You're slandering a CIA agent!" McCain interrupted again.
"He is complicit. I don't know if it's about a political future ... for him to sit there and say evidence has to be overwhelming and he heard no overwhelming evidence, I want to know which hearings he's sitting at," Sunny continued, as the audience erupted in applause.
"It's easy to get a cheap applause line here, it just is" McCain said, "And that's fine, take your cheap applause line." Hostin wasn't having that though, saying, "It's not a cheap applause line, maybe they agree."
"Let me speak," Meghan shot back. Sunny: "You've been speaking a lot."
As the conversation continued, McCain thanked Hurd for "putting his life on the line" as a part of the CIA and showed her support for "all veterans." Ana, meanwhile, said she liked Hurd and appreciated his service, but also believed he was "acting politically" with his stance.
With no Whoopi Goldberg around to break everything up, the women continued to speak over each other, before Meghan said, "We have to go to a commercial, really." After Ana finished her thought, they finally did.